8 Best Ina Garten Pumpkin Pie Recipes To Try Today

It’s certainly true that the pumpkin pie is a widely popular dessert, and one that is enjoyed largely during the fall, and around the Halloween season.

8 Best Ina Garten Pumpkin Pie Recipes To Try Today

Largely popular in the United States, where it has become symbolic of the season, there are now numerous recipes you can use to create the perfect pumpkin pie at home. 

One of the most popular tv chefs, Ina Garten – the host of the Food Network show Barefoot Contessa, and an esteemed chef and author in her own right – has numerous dessert recipes to choose from, many of them focused around the pumpkin pie, and the various ways it can be made. 

But this begs the question: what are the best Ina Garten pumpkin pie recipes, and what makes them so special (see also “Best Ina Garten Pie Crust Recipes“)? 

Ina Garten Pumpkin Pie Recipes: Our Top 8 Picks

Now that we know a little more about Ina Garten, and the pumpkin pie in general, it is now time for us to take a closer look at some of the best recipes on the market – each of them offering something a little different, and allowing you to create your own perfect pumpkin pie. 

So, without further ado, let’s get started!

1. Ina Garten’s Pumpkin Pie (W/ Rum & Whipped Cream)

First on this list we have this pumpkin pie with rum and whipped cream by Ina Garten (Also check out Amazing Ina Garten Pie Recipes). 

This is a great addition to any Thanksgiving celebration – or indeed any celebration throughout the year – and offers a great tasting dessert with plenty of spice from the rum, nutmeg, and the other various spices. 

Delicious, creamy, and with the perfect combinations of sweetness, spice, and tartness, this really is a great way to bring in the harvest season, and to share a meal with family and friends – just make sure they’re over 21!

2. Ina Garten’s Pumpkin Roulade With Ginger Buttercream

Next we have something a little different for your Thanksgiving celebrations – offering something different from the usual pie, and instead having a pumpkin and ginger roulade, a sweet cake roll that can be sliced and enjoyed by all the family. 

This is a delicious and creamy dessert that remains much moister than pie, and allows you to really make your dish go further.

As such, it is a great thing to prepare for larger events with more people, wherein you can slice everyone off a piece for them to enjoy. 

For something a little different – or for those who don’t like pies – then this is certainly one to try!

3. Ina Garten’s Pumpkin Flan With Maple Caramel

Somewhat similar to a pie in appearance, albeit much fresher and creamier, we have this pumpkin flan with maple caramel from Ina Garten. 

Softer and fresher than a pie, this is great for those living in hotter climates, and who might prefer something lighter and with less pastry than the classic Thanksgiving dessert. 

Delicious, soft, and devilishly moreish, this really is what the holidays are about – indulgence, and coming together to share great, wholesome food with the people you care about the most. 

4. Pumpkin Pie With Stem Ginger Cream

This is a much more rustic take on the classic, but it really does look the part – and after one bite you will be coming back for seconds in no time. 

With a crunchy, rustic biscuit base, and an open-topped, gooey pumpkin center, this is definitely different from what you might be used to.

However, after one serving of this it will quickly become a yearly tradition that you and your family will share for years to come. 

A perfect combination of sweetness, tangy pumpkin, and soft, wholesome ginger cream, this really is a great way to celebrate the harvest season, and to enjoy some good home cooking with family, friends, and loved ones. 

This really isn’t one you want to miss out on!

5. Pumpkin Cream Cheese Pie

A pumpkin pie with a twist, this pumpkin and cream cheese pie might sound unusual at face value, but it really is a game changer – not to mention one that you will soon assimilate into your Thanksgiving repertoire. 

The important component of this recipe is the cheese, which helps to make an otherwise (potentially) dry dessert far more creamy and moist – and ensures that it is a welcome blast of indulgence to follow any Thanksgiving banquet. 

Luscious, delicate, and incredibly moreish, this is a great way to enjoy the taste and flavors of pumpkin pie, albeit with a welcome twist.

However, it is important to remember that refrigeration is key, especially in between cooking and serving, and with regards to storage when not being used. 

6. Vegan Pumpkin Pie

Of course, not everyone can consume regular pumpkin pie – with one of these groups being vegans.

After all, many of the ingredients in pastry and pies come from animals – such as butter, milk, and eggs – and this means that alternatives will need to be made to accommodate family members and friends. 

Luckily, there have never been so many vegan options, and this Ina Garten-inspired recipe is a great way to make everyone feel a part of the fun in spite of their lifestyle choices and dietary requirements. 

Filled with the same sweet pumpkin filling, and all the warming spice you want for those chilling fall nights, this vegan pumpkin pie is a great way to enjoy the holidays guilt-free. 

7. Pumpkin Pie With Maple/Pecan Streusel

Maple syrup is another ingredient that is constantly associated with the fall and wintertime – and it has become a seasonal favorite for households all around the United States.

If your family loves maple syrup, then why not combine it with another holiday favorite to create your new favorite Thanksgiving dessert? 

This pumpkin pie takes everything you would expect from a regular holiday dessert, and amps it up to eleven – combining the sweetness and the spice with sticky, wholesome maple syrup, and crunchy pecans to add a much needed texture to this seasonal favorite. 

This really is a taste of the holiday season, and is the perfect accompaniment to all manner of seasonal festivities and get-togethers.

What’s more, when your family and friends have a bite of this gooey, sweet, delectable dessert, they will soon be coming back for seconds (or even thirds). 

8. Chocolate-Swirled Pumpkin Pie

Last on our list, but by no means least, we have this chocolate-swirled pumpkin pie – a recipe that takes an already indulgent holiday dessert, and does the only sensible thing: adds chocolate to it. 

This is a great dessert for any special get-together with family and friends, and really does have everything you could ever want from a wholesome homemade dessert.

With the tanginess of the pumpkin filling, the spice of the seasoning, and the delicious, creaminess of the chocolate, this really does feel like the holidays. 

If you can think of a better way to celebrate the festive season, and beat the cold weather while you are at it, then you are welcome to try.

However, few desserts bring as many things to the table as this great dessert, and it will soon become a firm favorite amongst future family gatherings. 

Hungry for more? Try this amazing pumpkin bread.

Frequently Asked Questions

Now that we have taken a look at the recipes in more detail, we will now answer some frequently asked questions you might be interested in. 

Can Pumpkin Pie Be Eaten Year Round? 

Yes! While pumpkin pie has a lot of associations with fall and Halloween in particular, it can also be enjoyed at any time of the year, or indeed as part of any celebration, special occasion, or gathering. 

Where Did Pumpkin Pie Originate? 

While the pumpkin pie native to North America, it actually found its roots in Tudor-era England, when the pumpkin was introduced by the French, and the flesh quickly became a variety of filling.

However, the pumpkin pie as we know it today was created by early American colonists. 

Why Is Pumpkin Pie Eaten In The Fall? 

The image of the pumpkin, and in turn pumpkin pie, has long been associated with the fall and harvest time – with the distinctive orange color and specific flavorings of the pumpkin lending itself to the season, as well as harvest events like Halloween, where they are eaten and carved for decoration.  

Final Thoughts

And there we have it, everything you need to know about Ina Garten, and the 8 best pumpkin pie recipes that you can find online today. 

It is true that pumpkin pie has become a seasonal favorite in the United States, and is a popular treat for the fall and Halloween celebrations.

However, without the proper recipe, this American dream can soon become a disappointing nightmare. 

So if you are looking for the best pumpkin pie recipes, then be sure to give some of these a try. Something tells me you won’t be disappointed!

8 Best Ina Garten Pumpkin Pie Recipes To Try Today

Recipe by Barbara HuntCourse: Recipes


Prep time


Cooking time





Want to find the best Ina Garten pumpkin pie recipes? Check out this handy guide for everything you need to know!


  • Pick a recipe from above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review
Barbara Hunt


No Spam, just delicious recipes, cooking tips and quality kit for your kitchen!

Scroll to Top