8 Amazing Paula Deen Shepherds Pie Recipes To Try Today

Shepherd’s pie is an incredibly popular dish, loved by many around the world. As the name suggests, a traditional shepherd’s pie is made with lamb mince, along with an assortment of vegetables and mashed potato on top.

8 Amazing Paula Deen Shepherds Pie Recipes To Try Today

On the other hand, a cottage pie is traditionally made with beef mince rather than lamb, as well as vegetables and potato on top. 

While there is a distinction between the two, the terms are often used interchangeably. So, in this article, you will notice a collection of differing meat fillings in these pies, including lamb, beef, and even turkey. 

About Paula Deen

Paula Deen is the queen of hearty, Southern American food. Born in 1947, she is known for her wide array of accessible and easy dishes that will bring a smile to your face every day.

She has had careers on television but is also a chef and cookbook author with hundreds of mouthwatering recipes under her belt (see also “Female Chef Instant Pot Cookbooks You Do Not Want to Miss“). 

This wonderful chef describes her food as “farmhouse cooking” – it’s rustic, feel-good, home-style cooking that everyone can get behind.

If that sounds like something you like, and you have an affinity for shepherd’s pie, then you’re in the right place. 

Let’s take a look at Paula Deen’s takes on this classic, and see what she has to offer. You won’t regret making a single one of these!

1. Paula Deen’s Shepherd’s Pie

Shepherd’s pie might sound intimidating, but it’s a lot easier than you think – especially if you follow this recipe.

Paula Deen’s shepherd’s pie calls for instant biscuit mix for the top instead of mashed potatoes, which already adds something new and interesting to the classic (Also check out Paula Deen Mashed Potato Recipes).

Of course, you could use mashed potatoes if you like, but why pass up on something different? 

While the recipe calls for ground meat, since this is a shepherd’s pie, we would recommend using ground lamb. This will ensure that you stay true to the traditional shepherd’s pie.

With a handful of other ingredients like sour cream, red potatoes, and onion, you can get this ready in no time.

2. Shepherd’s Pie from Leftover Beef Roast And Mashed Potatoes

It can be difficult to figure out what to do with leftovers sometimes, but if you have leftover beef roast and mashed potatoes, we’ve got you!

Turning your leftovers into a rich and creamy shepherd’s pie is not a choice you will regret making, and you are only going to wish that you tried it sooner. 

You will need your leftover pot roast and mash, or another kind of potato that could be used to add to the mix.

This recipe calls for an instant biscuit mix, but you could opt for the good old mashed potatoes for the topping if you like. Use plenty of fresh herbs to bring the dish to life, and do not forget that sour cream! 

3. Christmas Shepherd’s Pie

This delicious Christmas shepherd’s pie calls for cornbread mix to pull everything together and set it apart from the rest.

On top of that, you will need russet potatoes, mixed vegetables, onion, tomato sauce, milk, butter, and a handful of other basics. 

You will get delightfully rich and creamy mashed potatoes, but you can prepare them how you like.

If there is a particular mashed potato recipe that you are in love with that will work for a recipe like this, we encourage you to use it! This is the time to use all your favorites and get a dish that you really love.

4. Lighter Christmas Shepherd’s Pie

Instead of using ground beef like the above Christmas pie does, here, we will be using ground turkey! This is naturally leaner and still makes for a fantastic pie.

Other ingredients you are going to need will include portobello mushrooms, garlic, canola oil, butter, reduced-fat milk, reduced-sodium beef broth, and a handful of others. 

Even though this is the lighter version of the aforementioned Christmas shepherd’s pie, you definitely are not losing any flavor.

This recipe is just as delicious and worth the time it takes to prepare and make. Everyone is going to love it.

5. Turkey And Sweet Potato Shepherd’s Pie

If you love sweet potatoes and turkey, then this shepherd’s pie could be perfect for you. The flavors work together like a match made in heaven, and it’s so easy to make.

All you need is butter, sweet potatoes, carrots, celery, onions, parsnips, egg, turkey, and a handful of other things.

The low-sodium chicken broth and cream cheese in this recipe really help to bring everything together, so don’t skip out!

Fresh works work especially well with this recipe. The recipe calls for fresh thyme and rosemary, but you could add a few more if you like.

Just don’t forget the basics like Worcestershire sauce and good old salt and pepper, too. Without those, your dish will definitely be lacking!

6. Lighter Chipotle Shepherd’s Pie

If you love chipotle (not the restaurant, the peppers!), you will love this chipotle shepherd’s pie recipe.

For this recipe, you will need ground beef, cubed sweet potatoes, zucchini, chipotles en adobo, yellow squash, chicken broth, cheese, cumin, and plenty of garlic, among other things. 

This easy recipe is full of fantastic vegetables and tasty seasoning options, so it will be great for drawing in any veggie haters.

The flavors here work like a dream, but you could always add more if you know your way around the kitchen!

7. Air Fryer Shepherd’s Pie Stuffed Potatoes

Looking for a fun shepherd’s pie recipe with a twist? Why not try out this one, with shepherd’s pie stuffed potatoes?

It’s a lot easier than you think, and you will need gravy mix, milk, leftover roast beef, large russet potatoes, and a handful of other simple ingredients. 

If you have an air fryer, you will get the best results. However, this recipe can also be made using a simple oven, it may just take a little longer!

Whatever you use, make sure you don’t burn yourself trying to get this delicious meal down!

8. Mini Shepherd’s Pie

Everyone loves mini foods, right? You do, we do, Paula Deen does, too! Why not make some mini shepherd’s pies if you are in the mood for some mini food?

You can use all the shepherd’s pie basics like ground beef, onion, and garlic, as well as plenty of veggies. 

This recipe calls for a can of refrigerated buttermilk biscuits, as well as some delightful garlic and herb cheese. Doesn’t that already sound delicious?

The biscuits will be used to make delightful muffin cups to hold the pie, so they are perfect for snacking on. This makes the recipes a fantastic option for events where you want little finger foods.

Final Thoughts

Which shepherd’s pie recipe are you going to make next? The air fryer shepherd’s pie stuffed potatoes look like a fun dish to try out, and it is something the whole family can enjoy!

Whichever dish you decide to make next, you are going to fall in love with it, so you will probably end up making it again. 

If you really love shepherd’s pie, why not work your way through the list and find out which one is your favorite? You might make some fun and interesting discoveries along the way.

When you get the recipe down, you might even come up with something of your own!

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is The Difference Between A Shepherd’S Pie And A Cottage Pie?

Shepherd’s pie is traditionally made with ground lamb, while cottage pie uses ground beef. Both recipes typically have mashed potatoes on top and an assortment of vegetables such as carrots and peas with the meat. 

What Seasoning Usually Goes Into Shepherd’S Pie?

Rosemary and thyme are great for shepherd’s pie, as well as garlic, salt, pepper, and onion. However, you can season your shepherd’s pie however you like, and even add chili and paprika to give it a little kick. 

Do You Need To Use Mashed Potatoes On Top Of A Shepherd’S Pie?

Not necessarily! If you would like to stick to the traditional version of the pie, then you will want to use mashed potatoes.

However, if you feel like being a little more adventurous in your culinary endeavors, you can use a biscuit mix like Paula Deen often does!

This adds something a little different to the pie and makes the dish feel a little more fun. 

Which Kind Of Meat Is Best For Shepherd’S Pie?

While lamb is the traditional meat used for shepherd’s pie, you can use any that you prefer.

Turkey is a good option if you are looking to keep the pie a little lighter, but you may need to alter the recipe slightly to ensure it keeps its moisture.

Beef can also be used, and you can use low-fat or regular ground beef, depending on your preferences. 

8 Amazing Paula Deen Shepherds Pie Recipes To Try Today

Recipe by Barbara HuntCourse: Paula Deen, Recipes


Prep time


Cooking time






  • Pick a recipe from above
  • Click the recipe name and visit the website
  • Collect the ingredients and the food
  • Enjoy – don’t forget to leave a review
Barbara Hunt


No Spam, just delicious recipes, cooking tips and quality kit for your kitchen!

Scroll to Top