9 Comforting Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipes To Try At Home

Chicken pot pie, a comfort food classic, embodies the essence of home cooking.

Martha Stewart, a household name in culinary expertise, offers a variety of chicken pot pie recipes, each catering to different tastes and occasions.

This article explores these diverse recipes, summarizing their unique characteristics and providing insights into their preparation.

Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipes

Traditional Chicken Pot Pies

First up, we have the classics – traditional chicken pot pies that bring back memories of grandma’s kitchen growing up.

Crumbly, buttery pastry and packed with filling, these Martha Stewart chicken pot pies are true belly warmers.

1. Classic Chicken Pot Pie

The classic chicken pot pie is a hallmark of traditional American comfort food.

This first recipe begins with a homemade pastry crafted from all-purpose flour, sugar, salt, butter, and ice water, resulting in a flaky, buttery crust.

The filling is a hearty amalgamation of diced onion, carrots, peas, and shredded chicken bathed in a rich chicken broth.

Each step, from sautéing the vegetables to simmering the broth, builds layers of flavor, culminating in a filling that is both comforting and satisfying.

The pie can be made ahead and frozen, offering a convenient, heartwarming meal for any day of the week.

2. Individual Chicken Pot Pies

Individual chicken pot pies offer a delightful and personalized twist on the classic dish, perfect for single servings or a family-style meal where everyone gets their own pie.

This recipe begins with a whole chicken, simmered to perfection and then hand-shredded into bite-size pieces.

In a separate pot, a medley of Yukon gold potatoes, carrots, onion, and cremini mushrooms are sautéed in butter, enriched with a splash of cognac for depth.

Flour and a combination of reserved chicken stock and milk create a thick, creamy sauce enveloping the chicken and vegetables.

Fresh peas, parsley, and thyme are stirred in for freshness and flavor, with seasoning adjusted to taste.

Each individual ramekin is generously filled with this hearty mixture, then topped with a circle of puff pastry, slightly larger than the rim, for a snug fit.

When baked, the puff pastry rises into a flaky, golden-brown crust, contrasting beautifully with the rich, bubbling filling beneath.

These Individual Chicken Pot Pies offer the comfort of traditional pot pie in a format that feels special and tailored to each diner.

They’re perfect for a cozy family dinner, impressing guests, or even for making ahead and freezing for a convenient, satisfying meal anytime.

3. Easy Chicken Pot Pies

For those seeking a simpler, quicker alternative, these easy chicken pot pies are a perfect choice.

This recipe forgoes the traditional pastry for a puff pastry crust, offering convenience without compromising flavor.

The filling, a blend of onion, celery, carrots, green beans, and cooked chicken, provides a wholesome and nourishing core.

The inclusion of green beans adds a unique twist, while the use of puff pastry cuts down on preparation time, making this recipe a go-to for busy weeknights.

Healthy Chicken Pot Pie Recipes

If you’re health-conscious, but you don’t want to miss out on the joy of a good pie, we have a selection of recipes to keep you satisfied.

4. Healthy Chicken Pot Pie

For those looking for a healthier version, the healthy chicken pot pie is an ideal choice.

This recipe focuses on lightness and nutrition without sacrificing taste.

It features a phyllo dough crust, significantly lighter than traditional pastry, and a filling made with shallots, garlic, carrots, celery, and peas.

The use of poached chicken and reserved stock from the poaching process adds flavor without excess fat.

The inclusion of fresh herbs like parsley and tarragon provides an aromatic lift.

This pot pie variation is perfect for health-conscious individuals who crave the comfort of a pot pie but prefer a lighter meal.

5. A Healthier Chicken Pot Pie

This Chicken Pot Pie recipe stands out for its health-conscious approach, incorporating nutritious ingredients like barley and whole-wheat phyllo dough.

The use of whole-wheat phyllo dough instead of traditional pastry reduces the dish’s glycemic index while providing a satisfyingly crisp texture.

The filling begins with cooking barley until tender, then set aside.

Chicken breasts are seasoned, sautéed to golden perfection, and shredded.

In the same pan, onions, carrots, and shiitake mushrooms are sautéed in the remaining chicken juices, adding layers of flavor.

White wine is used to deglaze the pan, followed by a mixture of flour and low-sodium chicken stock to create a slightly thickened sauce.

The cooked barley and shredded chicken are then stirred into this rich mixture.

For assembly, the mixture is spooned into ramekins. Whole-wheat phyllo sheets, brushed with extra-virgin olive oil, are cut to size and placed atop each ramekin.

The pot pies are baked until the phyllo dough turns golden and the filling bubbles, offering a delightful contrast of textures and flavors.

This Chicken Pot Pie recipe is an excellent choice for those seeking a healthier version of the classic dish.

Martha Stewart’s Chicken Pot Pie Recipes With A Twist

If you really want to push the boat out and transform the classic chicken pot pie into something a little more exciting, we have a choice of recipes you’re going to love!

6. Chicken, Mushroom, And Bacon Pot Pies

The chicken, mushroom, and bacon pot pies are a gourmet treat for those who enjoy a more indulgent version of the classic dish.

This recipe borrows elements from coq au vin, featuring chicken pieces, bacon, and mushrooms, creating a rich and savory filling.

The combination of leeks, carrots, celery, potato, and red wine adds depth and complexity.

Topped with a homemade Pâte Brisée crust, these pot pies are a luxurious take on the traditional recipe, perfect for a special occasion or a cozy night in.

7. Arabian Gulf Pot Pies

The Arabian Gulf Pot Pies take inspiration from Middle Eastern cuisine, incorporating a blend of regional ingredients and spices for a distinctive flavor profile.

This variation uses ghee for cooking, adding a nutty depth to the dish.

The filling comprises chicken thighs, onions, garlic, serrano chile, and a medley of vegetables like carrots, turnips, eggplant, and zucchini.

The spice blend, a mix of traditional Arabic flavors, imparts a warm, aromatic character to the pot pies.

Topped with all-butter puff pastry, these pot pies are a celebration of cultural fusion, offering a unique and exotic take on the classic chicken pot pie.

8. Chicken Pot Pie With Brown-Butter Crust

This chicken pot pie with brown butter crust is an exquisite variation that elevates the classic dish with its unique and flavorful brown-butter crust.

The filling is a rich mix of chicken, leeks, celery, cremini mushrooms, and butternut squash, seasoned perfectly and thickened with flour.

Fresh thyme, white wine, peas, and parsley add layers of flavor, creating a filling that’s both traditional and refreshingly new.

The crust, the star of this recipe, involves browning butter until it develops a nutty aroma and golden color.

The butter is then cooled, combined with all-purpose flour and salt, and processed until it reaches the right consistency.

The dough is chilled, rolled out, and placed over the savory filling in a baking dish.

To complete the dish, the pot pie is baked until the crust turns a beautiful golden brown and the filling bubbles with rich, comforting flavors.

This version of chicken pot pie, with its brown-butter crust and hearty filling, is perfect for those who appreciate a classic comfort dish with a gourmet twist.

9. Chicken-Pot-Pie Pasta

We have a confession – this isn’t an actual pie, but it’s so good and encompasses the comforting pot pie filling, so we had to include it here.

Chicken-pot-pie Pasta is a creative reinterpretation of the classic pot pie, transforming it into a comforting pasta dish.

This recipe cleverly incorporates the essence of chicken pot pie into a pasta format, using penne or a similar tubular pasta as the base.

The sauce, enriched with green beans, onion, celery, carrots, chicken broth, and cooked chicken, mirrors the traditional pot pie filling.

This innovative approach offers a delightful alternative for those who love the flavors of chicken pot pie but are looking for something different from the standard pie format.

Final Thoughts

Martha Stewart’s chicken pot pie recipes offer something for everyone, from traditional favorites to modern twists.

Each recipe caters to different tastes, dietary preferences, and occasions, showcasing the versatility and enduring appeal of this beloved dish.

Whether you’re in the mood for a classic comfort meal, a quick weeknight dinner, or an exotic fusion of flavors, these chicken pot pie variations are sure to satisfy your culinary cravings.

If you want to try some different fillings, we have another post about Martha’s pot pies here.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is my chicken pot pie bland?

Your chicken pot pie may be bland if it lacks sufficient seasoning or if the ingredients used do not have enough inherent flavor. Enhancing the dish with a variety of herbs, spices, and adequate salt can significantly improve its taste.

Why is my chicken pot pie watery?

A watery chicken pot pie is often the result of insufficient thickening of the filling or the inclusion of ingredients with high water content that release moisture during cooking. To avoid this, ensure your sauce is adequately thickened with flour or another thickening agent before assembling the pie.

What is the sauce made of in chicken pot pie?

The sauce in a chicken pot pie is typically made from a base of flour and butter (forming a roux), combined with chicken broth and sometimes milk or cream, which creates a rich, creamy, and flavorful sauce to bind the filling ingredients.

9 Comforting Martha Stewart Chicken Pot Pie Recipes To Try At Home

Recipe by Barbara HuntCourse: Other Recipes


Prep time


Cooking time






  • Choose a pot pie recipe
  • Gather your ingredients
  • Make your pie
  • Dig in!
Barbara Hunt


No Spam, just delicious recipes, cooking tips and quality kit for your kitchen!

Scroll to Top