The 9 Best Martha Stewart Pot Pie Recipes

Surely, you’ve heard of Martha Stewart, the maven of all things domestic, whose culinary prowess has made her a household name.

Today, we’re diving into the delectable world of pot pies, guided by Stewart’s expert touch. pot pies, a comforting classic in American cuisine, are a testament to Martha’s skill in turning humble ingredients into culinary masterpieces.

Now, pot pies might be your grandma’s favorite, but with Martha’s touch, they’re getting a modern makeover.

Martha Stewart aPot Pie Recipes

Classic chicken, hearty beef, or a kick of curry – these recipes aren’t just meals; they’re a celebration of good eats, simplified for your kitchen adventures.

Whether you’re a kitchen pro or still figuring out which end of the spatula is up, Martha’s Pot Pie Guide is your ticket to savory success.

So, get ready to sprinkle a dash of Martha’s magic in your own kitchen as we unravel the secrets behind these scrumptious pot pies.

It’s not just about cooking; it’s about making every bit a taste of Martha’s culinary charm right in your own home.

Chicken Pot Pies

1. Classic Chicken Pot Pie

Get a real hit of nostalgia with Martha Stewart’s classic chicken pot pie. A buttery, flaky crust encases a rich, savory filling of tender chicken, vegetables, and a velvety homemade gravy. It’s comfort food at its finest, offering a taste of timeless culinary tradition.

Cooking Tip: For a golden, crispy crust, brush the top with an egg wash before baking. This adds a beautiful sheen and enhances the visual appeal of your pot pie.

Pairing Dish: Serve this classic delight with a side of garlic mashed potatoes. The creamy potatoes complement the savory flavors of the pot pie, creating a satisfying and hearty meal.

2. Individual Chicken Pot Pies

For a simpler touch, Martha Stewart’s individual chicken pot pies are a busy weeknight’s dream. These individual servings boast the same comforting flavors as the classic version, but some together effortlessly for a quick and delicious family dinner.

Cooking Tip: Opt for store-bought puff pastry to streamline the process without sacrificing taste. It delivers a flaky and golden finish with minimal effort.

Pairing Dish: Pair these easy chicken pot pies with a crisp, mixed green salad for a refreshing contrast that adds a touch of brightness to the meal.

3. Lighter Chicken Pot Pie

Indulge guilt-free in Martha Stewart’s lighter chicken pot pie. This healthier rendition maintains all the luscious flavors of the classic but with a lighter touch, making it a perfect option for those mindful of their calorie intake.

Cooking Tip: You can substitute the whole milk with low-fat milk in the sauce for a lighter, yet still creamy, consistency.

Pairing Dish: Serve with a side of steamed broccoli or a fresh Caprese salad for a wholesome and balanced meal.

4. Curried Chicken Pot Pie

Martha Stewart’s curried chicken pot pie brings a bold twist to the traditional recipe. This exotic variation infused the creamy chicken filling with aromatic curry spices, creating a tantalizing fusion of flavors.

Cooking Tip: Adjust the level of curry according to your taste preferences, and feel free to add a squeeze of lime before serving for a citrusy zing.

Pairing Dish: Pair this curried delight with basmati rice or naan to soak up the flavorful sauce and complete the exotic experience.

Did we whet your appetite? We have more chicken pot pies from Martha here.

Vegetable And Seafood Pot Pies

5. Chunky Vegetable Pot Pie

The next recipe celebrates the bountiful goodness of fresh vegetables. Packed with a colorful array of hearty veggies, this pot pie is a vegetarian delight with a robust and satisfying taste.

Cooking Tip: Opt for a mix of root vegetables like carrots, parsnips, and sweet potatoes for a hearty and earthy flavor profile.

Pairing Dish: Pair this chunky vegetable pot pie with a side of quinoa or a simple green salad to enhance the nutritional value and add a light touch to the meal.

6. Winter Vegetable Pot Pie With Cheddar Biscuit Topping

Martha Stewart’s winter vegetable pot pie with cheddar biscuit topping is a seasonal masterpiece. The savory filling, featuring winter vegetables, is crowned with golden cheddar biscuits, creating a comforting dish perfect for colder months.

Cooking Tip: Add a pinch of thyme to the biscuit dough for an aromatic boost that complements the winter vegetables.

Pairing Dish: Serve alongside a warm cup of tomato soup or a fresh, mixed salad to balance the richness of the pot pie and add a burst of contrasting flavors.

7. Spicy Seafood Pot Pies

Martha Stewart’s spicy seafood pot pies bring a kick to the table with a delightful seafood twist. Succulent shrimp, scallops, and a spicy tomato-based sauce are nestled beneath a golden crust, creating a dish that’s as vibrant as it is flavorful.

Cooking Tip: You can adjust the level of spice by controlling the amount of red pepper flakes, catering to your personal heat preference.

Pairing Dish: Pair these spicy seafood pot pies with a side of sautéed spinach or a light cucumber salad to complement the seafood’s freshness and balance the spice.

Beef Pot Pie Recipes

8. Italian Beef Pot Pies

Martha Stewart’s Italian beef pot pies bring a taste of Italy to the classic pot pie. Succulent beef, aromatic herbs, and a savory tomato-based sauce create a flavorful filling that transports your taste buds to the heart of Italian cuisine.

Cooking Tip: Infuse extra depth by adding a splash of red wine to the beef filling for a rich and robust flavor.

Pairing Dish: Pair this Italian-inspired delight with a side of garlic bread or a simple arugula salad for a satisfying and well-rounded meal.

9. Beef And Stout Pot Pie

Finally, Martha Stewart’s beef and stout pot pie is a hearty, British pub-inspired creation. Tender beef chunks simmered in a stout-infused gravy are encased in a golden, flaky crust, delivering a robust and satisfying flavor experience.

Cooking Tip: Use a dark stout for a more pronounced flavor, and consider adding a dash of Worcestershire sauce to enhance the umami notes.

Pairing Dish: Serve alongside mashed potatoes or buttered noodles to soak up the rich gravy and create a comforting and filling meal.

Final Thoughts

As we wrap up our journey through Martha Stewart’s amazing pot pie recipes, it feels like we’ve just shared a cozy kitchen chat with a dear friend who just so happens to be a culinary genius.

Martha Stewart, the queen of all things home and style, has sprinkled her magic into pot pies, turning them into delicious works of art.

Throughout these recipes, you can almost hear Martha’s friendly advice and taste the love she pours into her creations.

From the classic chicken pot pie to the hearty beef and spicy seafood twists, each dish is like a warm hug for a more kitchen-savvy friend.

Martha’s influence goes way beyond just recipes. It’s a lifestyle she generously shares – one that values simplicity, elegance, and a bit of playful experimentation. And ooh, the pot pies!

They’re not just meals; they’re little bits of comfort that connect us to the heart of home.

So, as we say goodbye to this delightful kitchen rendezvous, let’s carry a piece of Martha’s culinary wisdom with us.

Here’s to recreating these fantastic pot pies in our own kitchens, sprinkling a bit of Martha’s charm into our daily cooking adventures.

Hungry for more? Learn how to make the perfect Martha Stewart roast dinner here.


Are Martha Stewart’s pot pie recipes suitable for beginners?

Absolutely! Martha Stewart, understanding the varied skill levels of her audience, ensures that her pot pie recipes are accessible to both novice and seasoned cooks alike. The instructions provided are clear and concise, fostering a welcoming environment for those venturing into the delightful world of cooking

Where can I find the ingredients for these pot pie recipes?

Most ingredients for Martha Stewart’s pot pie recipes are readily available at your local grocery store. Check the article for specific details on each recipe and make your shopping list accordingly.

Can I freeze Martha Stewart’s pot pies for later?

Indeed, many of Martha Stewart’s pot pie recipes are designed with practicality in mind, offering the convenience of freezing for later enjoyment. Her recipes often include valuable tips on storage and reheating, making them ideal for those embracing the concept of meal preparation and planning.

Are these pot pie recipes time-consuming?

Martha Stewart recognizes the importance of time in the kitchen. While some of her pot pie recipes may require a bit more dedication, she often presents variations that cater to individuals seeking quicker options without compromising on the rich and nuanced flavors that define her culinary creations.

Are there video tutorials for Martha Stewart’s pot pie recipes?

While the article focuses on written recipes, you can find video content featuring Martha Stewart demonstrating various cooking techniques on her official platforms. Explore her channels for additional guidance.

The 9 Best Martha Stewart Pot Pie Recipes

Recipe by Barbara HuntCourse: Other Recipes


Prep time


Cooking time






  • Choose a recipe
  • Collect your ingredients
  • Prepare your pie
  • Enjoy.
Barbara Hunt


No Spam, just delicious recipes, cooking tips and quality kit for your kitchen!

Scroll to Top