The 8 Best Martha Stewart Potato Salad Recipes

Step into Martha Stewart’s kitchen, and let’s talk potato salad! We’re about to uncover the ins and outs of Martha’s world of flavors.

Imagine yourself at the table, surrounded by good company and even better potato salads, all thanks to Martha’s culinary genius.

Martha Stewart, the queen of elegance, has handpicked eight potato salad recipes that are nothing short of amazing.

martha stewart potato salad

We’re not just talking about your run-of-the-mill salads – these recipes redefine the classic dish in the most delicious way.

From casual backyard hangouts to fancy dinner parties, Martha’s got a potato salad for every occasion. And guess what? We’re here to spill the beans on how she does it.

Get ready for a laid-back chat about the fantastic ingredients and kitchen tricks that make Martha’s potato salads the talk of the town.

Whether you’re a kitchen pro or just starting your cooking journey, Martha Stewart’s potato salad recipes are like a warm welcome into the world of fantastic flavors.

So, grab a seat, and let’s dig into the artistry of potato salads, Martha-style. Get ready for something seriously tasty!

Classic Potato Salads

1. Potato Salad

Elevate the classic potato salad to a new level of culinary delight. This recipe combines perfectly cooked potatoes with a creamy dressing, crisp veggies, and a hint of tanginess.

It’s a versatile dish suitable for any occasion, from picnics to family dinners. Customize with your favorite herbs for a personal touch.

Cooking Tip: Boil potatoes until just tender to maintain their texture. Mix the dressing separately before gently folding it into the potatoes to ensure an even coating without mashing the delicate spuds. For added flavor, let the salad chill in the fridge for a few hours before serving.

Pairing Dish: Pair this timeless potato salad with grilled burgers or a barbecue for a classic American feast. Its creamy texture and balanced flavors also make it an excellent side dish for fried chicken or a hearty sandwich.

2. All-American Potato Salad

Embrace the quintessential American potato salad that graces tables across the nation. Martha’s favorite rendition combines russet potatoes, hard-boiled eggs, and a tangy mustard-mayo dressing.

This timeless recipe captures the essence of picnics and summer gatherings, promising a crowd-pleaser with every bite.

Cooking Tip: Use waxy potatoes for a firmer texture, and toss them in the dressing while they’re still warm to absorb maximum flavor. Don’t forget a sprinkle of paprika for a classic finish touch.

Pairing Dish: Serve the all-American potato salad alongside grilled hot dogs and corn on the cob for a patriotic Fourth of July celebration. Its versatility also complements fried chicken or a juicy steak.

3. Martha’s Favorite Potato Salad

Dive into Martha’s favorite potato salad, a dish close to Martha’s heart that takes the classic potato salad on a joyous flavor ride. Picture this: perfectly boiled golden potatoes cuddled in a creamy mix of mayo, Dijon mustard, and fresh herbs.

It’s like a cozy hug for your taste buds, transforming ordinary gatherings into unforgettable feasts.

Cooking Tip: For an extra dose of creamy bliss, pop Martha’s favorite potato salad in the fridge for at least an hour before serving. Trust me, your patience will be rewarded!

Pairing Dish: Match this heavenly potato salad with some grilled lemon herb chicken – it’s like they were made for each other. The zesty chicken dances with the creamy potatoes, creating a taste sensation.

Herb-Infused And Zesty Potato Salads

4. Lemony Potato Salad

Brighten up your palate with Martha’s zesty, lemony potato salad. The addition of fresh lemon juice imports a citrusy kick, elevating the dish with a burst of refreshing flavor.

This rendition is a delightful departure from the ordinary, perfect for those seeking a lighter and more vibrant potato salad experience.

Cooking Tip: Add the lemon juice to the dressing gradually, tasting as you go, to achieve the perfect balance of acidity. Finishing with chopped fresh herbs like parsley or dill enhances the salad’s overall freshness.

Pairing Dish: Complement the lemony potato salad with grilled fish or shrimp for a refreshing seafood pairing. Its tangy profile also makes it an excellent choice alongside roast chicken or a light pasta dish.

5. Herbed Celery-Potato Salad

Experience the marriage of earthy herbs and crispy celery in Martha’s herbed celery-potato salad.

This rendition introduces a delightful crunch, creating a symphony of textures and flavors. It’s a refreshing twist on the classic, bringing a garden-fresh essence to your table.

Cooking Tip: Chop the celery finely for a subtle crunch, and mix the herbs into the dressing to infuse the salad with its aromatic goodness. For added depth, let the salad marinate for a bit before serving.

Pairing Dish: Pair this herbed celery potato salad with grilled chicken or a light quiche for a garden-inspired meal. Its herbal notes also make it an ideal companion for grilled vegetables or a simple frittata.

6. French Potato Salad

Transport your taste buds to France with Martha’s sophisticated French Potato Salad. Ditching the mayo, this recipe features a Dijon vinaigrette that has a tangy and savory essence.

It’s an elegant twist on the classic, perfect for those seeking a lighter and more nuanced potato salad experience.

Cooking Tip: Allow the potatoes to absorb the vinaigrette while they’re still warm for optimal flavor. Toss in ingredients like capers or shallots to enhance the salad’s French flair.

Pairing Dish: Serve the French potato salad alongside grilled salmon or a delicate quiche for a Parisian-inspired meal. Its lightness also makes it an excellent side for roast pork or a selection of artisanal cheeses.

Warm And Spiced Potato Salads

7. Spiced Potato Salad

Ignite your taste buds with Martha’s spiced potato salad, a fusion of bold flavors and comforting warmth.

Infused with spices like cumin and paprika, this recipe adds a kick to the classic dish, creating a memorable culinary experience for those who crave a bit of heat.

Cooking Tip: Toast the spices lightly before incorporating them into the dressing to enhance their aromatic qualities. Adjust the spice levels according to your preference for a personalized touch.

Pairing Dish: Pair the spiced potato salad with grilled sausages or spicy barbecue for a bold and flavorful feast. Its robust profile also makes it an excellent accompaniment to grilled lamb chops or a hearty chili.

8. Warm Potato Salad

Embrace the cozy comfort of Martha’s warm potato salad, a delightful departure from the child norm. This rendition features tender potatoes tossed in a savory dressing, offering a soothing and hearty twist on the classic.

It’s the perfect choice for colder days or when you crave a comforting side dish.

Cooking Tip: Steam or boil the potatoes until just fork-tender, ensuring they retain their structure. Toss them in the warm dressing right before serving for an inviting and comforting experience.

Pairing Dish: Pair the warm potato salad with roasted chicken or a hearty stew for a comforting and satisfying meal. Its warmth also complements grilled sausages or a flavorful meatloaf.

Final Thoughts

In wrapping up our exploration of Martha Stewart and potato salad, it’s clear that her culinary prowess extends beyond the ordinary.

We’ve delved into a realm of flavors, textures, and culinary finesse that only Martha could curate. From classic renditions to innovative twists, each potato salad recipe bears the unmistakable hallmark of Stewart’s expertise.

Martha’s dedication to elevating the simple potato salad into a culinary masterpiece reflects her passion for bringing joy to the dining table. It’s not just about the ingredients; it’s about creating moments, sparking conversations, and fostering a sense of togetherness.

So, the next time you whip up Martha Stewart’s potato salads, know that you’re not just following a recipe – you’re channeling the spirit of a culinary icon.

With every bite, you’re savoring the essence of Martha’s kitchen, where creativity knows no bounds, and every dish is an opportunity to create lasting memories.

In the realm of potato salad, Martha Stewart has not just provided recipes; she’s shared a piece of her culinary soul.

Here’s to embracing the delightful world of Martha’s potato salads and infusing your gatherings with the warmth and flavor only she can inspire.

If you fancy a slightly lighter salad, take a look at some more options from Martha Stewart here.


Can I prepare Martha Stewart’s potato salads in advance for convenience?

Yes, many recipes allow for preparation ahead of time. Martha provides guidance on storing and reheating to ensure optimal flavor.

Are the ingredients in Martha Stewart’s recipes easy to find?

Most ingredients are common kitchen staples, ensuring you won’t have trouble sourcing them. Martha focuses on simplicity without compromising flavor.

Are Martha Stewart’s potato salad recipes suitable for beginners?

Absolutely! Martha provides step-by-step instructions and helpful tips, making her recipes accessible to cooks of all skill levels.

The 8 Best Martha Stewart Potato Salad Recipes

Recipe by Barbara HuntCourse: Cookbooks


Prep time


Cooking time






  • Choose a recipe
  • Gather your ingredients
  • Prep your dish
  • Serve!
Barbara Hunt


No Spam, just delicious recipes, cooking tips and quality kit for your kitchen!

Scroll to Top